List of panels

(P107)

The transformation and redefinition of honour, status and moral authority patterns in contemporary Africa

Location 2E05
Date and Start Time 27 June, 2013 at 17:00

Convenors

Dominique Connan (European University Institute, Florence) email
Emmanuelle Bouilly (Paris I University) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

We propose to discuss the recent trends regarding to distinction, honour and self-achievement patterns in contemporary Africa. It aims to explore the moral innovations by which wealth and domination are justified and embodied, out of any individual relationship of political accountability.

Long Abstract

This panel proposes to discuss the recent trends regarding to social distinction and self-achievement patterns in contemporary Africa. How, for instance, the financialization of African economies (Vallée), the structural adjustment policies of the 1990s and the subsequent growth of the private and non-governmental sectors do transform the moral economies of African societies ? How does it affect previous models of honour (Iliffe), respectability, and self-achievement (Banégas/Warnier) in the continent? What possible new ethoses do emerge from such changes? How does it lead to new forms of legitimization of wealth and economic accumulation and redistribution? This panel seeks to explore the moral transformations and innovations by which wealth and social domination are justified, disembodied or re-embodied out of individual and personalized relationship of social responsibility and political accountability; amongst the economic elite, but also the (allegedly) growing "middle class" of the continent. For instance, how can we document and study the growth and use of charity organizations, corporate social responsibility, voluntary work, international standards of management and governance or new religiosity? The panel also aims to analyse the way through which fortunes and economic status inherited of previous eras, acquired through both legal and illegal or criminal ways (Bayart/Hibou) domesticate or cope with these new discourses of justification. Not restricting the analysis to discourses, the discussion will also encompass the way such transformations can affect the aspirations, desirable lifestyles and material cultures.

Chair: Ms Emmanuelle Bouilly
Discussant: Dr Marie Pommerolle

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

Papers

Moral economies of neoliberalism in Africa: the case of economic fraud

Author: Jörg Wiegratz (University of Leeds)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Many African societies are characterised by economic fraud, corruption, debates about moral change, and anti-corruption/fraud campaigns. These dynamics are interrelated parts of the emergence and consolidation of moral economies of neoliberalism. Uganda is used as a case to analyse this phenomenon.

Long Abstract

Economic fraud and political corruption at both elite and non-elite levels are widespread and endemic in many African societies that have undergone neoliberal reforms and transformations in the past two decades. Public debates about the moral features and dynamics of contemporary societal and political-economic orders are prevalent. Discourses around moral decline and crisis, as well as moral revival, are intensive; so are the various state-orchestrated anti-corruption and anti-fraud campaigns. In this paper it is argued that these dynamics are interrelated parts of the emergence and consolidation of moral economies of neoliberalism in Africa. It uses the case of fraud in Uganda to analyse the key structures and processes that produce this neoliberal web of moral economies and sheds light on the distinctive features of the latter. It furthermore regards actually existing moralities as both an empirical and political phenomenon. To that end, it explores how aspects of political economy and moral economy are intertwined and interact and thus constitute specific political moral economies in the study case. In a final section, the paper advocates that more scholarship is needed (i) to study the (cultural) political economy of actually existing moral norms, and (ii) to track the political-moral-economic underpinnings of social practices in neoliberal Africa more generally. The study of the changing practices and morals of interacting with others in the economy - i.e. defrauding/harming others - is a fruitful starting point for such a project. Empirical material from Uganda is used to develop and drive the analysis throughout the paper.

Being a 'burgher': the moral economy of migration and achievement in Ghana

Author: Nauja Kleist (Danish Institute for International Studies)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

This paper examines the moral economy of migration and achievement in Ghana. It explores the local category of ‘Burghers’ – characterizing successful migrants from Western countries – analyzing their social and moral status, authority, and obligations vis-à-vis their families and communities.

Long Abstract

This paper examines the moral economy of migration and achievement in Ghana. It explores the local category of 'Burghers' - a term used to characterize successful migrants from Western and North African countries. Based on ethnographic fieldwork in 2012 and 2013, the paper analyzes the social and moral status of 'Burghers' as well as patterns of authority, obligations and expectations vis-à-vis their families and communities.

The paper argues that the position and status of 'Burghers' is ambivalent. On the one hand, 'Burghers' are widely admired for their material wealth, Western lifestyle, and ability to care well for their family members in Ghana. Furthermore being a 'Burgher' can be a way of surpassing and transforming social hierarchies and a fast mode of becoming a 'big man'. These aspects of the 'Burgher' position inspire notions of hope and achievement among young people in the region who often endeavor to realize their aspirations through irregular migration towards Europe or Libya.

On the other hand, however, 'Burghers' are seen as potentially morally corrupted by their life in the West and may quickly be dismissed as selfish and as lacking social accountability, or, if their migration projects do not succeed, as 'Burgher loose' - as 'failed migrants' and the antithesis of success. Likewise irregular migration is widely condemned among local authorities and the non-migrant established elite who promote education and regular migration as the morally and legally correct ways of achievement. There is thus a struggle between different moral economies and aspirations of success and status.

Elite Voluntary Associations and the Making of Private Narratives of Respectability in Contemporary Kenya

Author: Dominique Connan (European University Institute, Florence)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to explain the success of private club membership among the African private sector elite in contemporary Kenya. For the last 20 years, these social, sporting and service clubs have progressively become iconic of upper class sociability in Nairobi and Kenyan bigger cities.

Long Abstract

Clubs gather nowadays a membership of hundreds of prosperous professionals and executives, over golf courses, charity events or professional coaching sessions. Social and sports clubs indeed appeared during the first years of British colonization in East Africa, but the current growth of club membership owes to different social and historical processes than the sheer mimicry of colonial practices. Their success enlightens the local and global narrations in which African investment in these iconic avatars of bourgeois modernity are rooted. Such process is rooted in the formation of an urban upper class of professionals, managers and businesspersons; intimately related to the growth of a "private sector" which has to cope with the competition of political elites; and linked to the formation of a social group which understands itself as constituting a community of interests, sharing common imaginary of self-achievement, rooted in a nationalist vision of the country's development.

Clubs are significant in the making of trans-ethnic and trans-generational regimes of entrustment. They contribute to the promotion and actualization of elite lifestyles. Their membership mark a belonging to what we could term an imagined world bourgeoisie, a place where managers and professionals discuss and dream about Kenya becoming the Singapore or the Dubai of Africa. But clubs are also a contested ground, as they are also used to make-up inherited fortunes of uncertain origin, and to provide formerly corrupted businessmen and politicians with the bureaucratic attributes of respectability. And as private places, they represent a space where the origins of wealth and the responsibilities of social status are hardly questioned.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.