List of panels

(P105)

Uncertain transitions: democracy and the challenge of poverty in southern Africa

Location 2E04
Date and Start Time 29 June, 2013 at 09:00

Convenors

Arrigo Pallotti (Università di Bologna) email
Mario Zamponi (University of Bologna) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

Within the context of the multiple historical and political obstacles to the consolidation of democratic transitions in southern Africa, the panel focuses on how poverty and social inequalities may have contributed to undermining the legitimacy of liberal democracy in the region.

Long Abstract

In spite of the high expectations raised in the early 1990s by the end of the apartheid regime in South Africa, the independence of Namibia and the resolution of the civil war in Mozambique, the consolidation of liberal democracies in southern Africa has not been accomplished yet. While multiparty elections have become the norm in the region and good governance has been strengthened, the concentration of power in the presidency and the political and organizational weaknesses of opposition parties and civil society organizations still hamper the achievement of democratic consolidation. In addition to that, a falling voter turnout indicates a growing popular disenchantment with the institutions of democratic representation. Within the context of the multiple historical and political obstacles to the consolidation of democratic transitions in southern Africa, the panel focuses on how the persistence of poverty and social inequalities may have contributed to undermining the legitimacy of liberal democracy in the southern African countries. The national and international efforts aimed at fighting poverty and achieving the Millennium Development Goals notwithstanding, poverty and social destitution remain pervasive in southern Africa, while economic inequalities have been rapidly increasing. In particular, the panel will try to address the following questions: what role do poverty and social inequalities play in the contemporary politics of southern Africa? What are the features of the emerging social pacts in the region? What impact do current processes of redefinition of citizenship and rights in southern Africa exert on the transformation of democracy at the global level?

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

Papers

Governance, economic performance and popular welfare in Africa: is the link clear?

Author: Olivier M Mbodo (Université Laval)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Does democracy lead to popular welfare in Africa? During the 1990s,the Sub-Saharan region witnessed a second wave of democratization.Today many of new democracies in Africa have improved their growth rates.Unfortunately,this has not yet brought a broad-based prosperity.What are the reasons?

Long Abstract

This paper mainly seeks to discuss, in an African framework, the link between democracy and poverty reduction. Does democracy lead to popular welfare in Africa? The collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989 - followed by both the dismantling of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War - brought a lot of changes in global politics and economics. It goes without saying that these changes had an impact in Africa as well. During the 1990s, the Sub-Saharan region witnessed a second wave of democratization, the so called "Second revolution" (Omozuanvbo Ihonvbere, 2006). Today, many Sub-Saharan countries have completed the first phase of the democratization process and have laid the foundations of a democratic form of government (El-Khawas and Ndumbe, 2005). Peter Lewis (2012) notes that many of new democracies in Africa have improved their growth rates significantly. Unfortunately, Lewis (2012) asserts that the economic growth in the new African democracies has not yet brought a broad-based prosperity. This is confirmed by Fukuyama (2012) who argues that around the world, many democratic transitions have been stalled or threatened by the existence of large inequalities between rich and poor.

Hence, this discussion will investigate the reasons why the democratization and the economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa have failed to reduce poverty. It will also explore the conditions of a positive link between good governance and popular welfare in Africa.

Political participation and democratization in Zambia: do poverty levels affect voters' perspectives?

Author: Federico Battera (University of Trieste)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

This paper focuses on the relation between poverty levels and electoral participation in post-1991 Zambia

Long Abstract

By concentrating on electoral participation and poverty levels across provinces, this paper tries to provide an explanation to the fluctuating people attachment to party politics in post-1991 Zambia. Voter turnout will be analysed at the provincial level and a direct correlation between poverty and participation will be explored in order to detect its existence. In particular, since poverty levels were different between rural and urban provinces and governments have displayed different sensibilities towards urban and rural constituencies we would like to discover whether such differences do count for political participation. One of the major questions, indeed, which aroused recently in literature, is what drives African people to vote. While ethnic vote theory (Posner 2005) still dominates the debate a new trend in alternative explanations is gaining momentum. In the 00s, after the formation of the Patriotic Front (PF), a growing interest has been placed on inequalities and on the fight against poverty in electoral programmes of both governing party and the oppositions and through the policies enacted by governments with however ambiguous results in terms of voter turnout. In 2011, turnout rose moderately against 2008 elections, while rural constituencies did not show any significant difference in voter turnout against urban constituencies notwithstanding differences in poverty levels. So a combination of other factors seems to have been at work as well: an erosion of MMD approval after twenty years of uninterrupted hegemony and the ability of some emerging leaders to drive, as usual, the ethnic vote.

"Promoting sustainable pro-poor growth": the policy of poverty reduction in multi-party Malawi

Author: Mario Zamponi (University of Bologna)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

The paper intends to analyse the politics of development in Malawi after the introduction of the multi-party system in 1994 with a specific focus on poverty reduction

Long Abstract

The paper intends to analyse the politics of development in Malawi after the introduction of the multi-party system in 1994. The case of Malawi is presented within the framework of the contemporary debate and practices concerning both economic development and the initiatives of poverty reduction, having in mind both the relevance of the role of the fight against poverty in the international discourse of poverty reduction and of the process of democratic emancipation of the population.

The paper discusses the main government policies based on patterns and priorities of economic and social development which could deal with the unsolved question of poverty in one of the poorest countries of the world. The policies of poverty alleviation are closely linked to initiatives of land reform and rural development together with a policy of decentralisation. These issues are analysed considering both their specificities and their relationship with the broader topics of development and of poverty reduction.

The poverty of democracy in Tanzania

Author: Arrigo Pallotti (Università di Bologna)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Within the context of the current debate on democratization in Sub-Saharan Africa, the paper raises some relevant questions on the relationship between poverty and democracy in Tanzania and the future of democracy in the country

Long Abstract

After the election of President Ali Hassan Mwinyi in 1995, Tanzania abandoned ujamaa, the socialist model of nation-building it had pursued during the previous twenty years, and started implementing a package of neoliberal economic reforms. In addition, in 1992 the country abandoned the one-party state and reintroduced multiparty politics. The paper analyses the economic and social effects of shift from socialism to neoliberalism in Tanzania, and shows that the negative effects of the neoliberal economic reforms gradually eroded the political legitimacy of the Chama cha Mapinduzi, and fuelled the emergence of ethnic and religious tensions in the country. Within the context of the current debate on democratization in Sub-Saharan Africa, the paper raises important questions on the relationship between poverty and democracy in Tanzania and the future of democracy in the country.

Democratization, inequality and civil society in Mozambique

Author: Pekka Virtanen (University of Jyväskylä)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

The paper provides an analysis of the links between poverty, inequality, political protest and trust in state vs. civil society institutions among different groups and regions in Mozambique based on quantitative and qualitative data and situated in the historical context.

Long Abstract

The process of socio-economic transition from socialist single-party to liberal-democratic system in Mozambique started with economic reforms in the 1980s, followed by a move to multi-party democracy in 1994. The results have, however been contradictory. Although economic growth figures have been impressive following the peace accord of 1992, growth has been unequal and limited to a few foreign-dominated technology-intensive sectors while agricultural development has been neglected. After an initial phase of successful poverty reduction, inequality and poverty have again started to rise. At the same time the initial gains in democratization achieved in the first two national elections have largely been reversed in the following rounds, which reflect widespread disillusionment among citizens. The ruling party shows signs of increasingly authoritarian behaviour and open contempt for democratic institutions, while the opposition has become fragmented and weak. Civil society, which is supposed to have an important role in a liberal-democratic regime, has largely been co-opted or suppressed by the ruling party. The subsequent spread of discontent from the historically marginalised rural areas in the North and Center to previously privileged urban areas in the South has been reflected in a series of protest movements and violent demonstrations during the last few years.

The paper provides a review of the development of civil society in Mozambique, followed by an analysis of the links between poverty, inequality, political protest and trust in state vs. civil society institutions among different groups and regions based on quantitative (Afrobarometer) and qualitative data.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.